When a Person With Dementia Refuses Care: A Guide for Families

When a person living with dementia refuses help or says they do not want to move, families can find themselves in a difficult position. You want to respect their wishes and independence, but you may also be worried about their health, well-being or ability to live safely at home.

If you have a loved one with dementia who is refusing to go into care, it is important to recognize that refusal is not always stubbornness or resistance to change. Dementia can affect awareness, judgment, communication and the ability to recognize when help is needed.

Before trying to convince someone to accept care, consider what may be behind the response. Listening first can open the door to an approach that respects their wishes while addressing health or safety concerns.

Understanding Why Someone May Refuse Care

There are many reasons someone with dementia may say no to help. They may be afraid of losing independence, uncomfortable with an unfamiliar caregiver coming into their home or worried about leaving a place that feels safe and familiar.

In some cases, the person may genuinely believe they do not need assistance.

One possible reason is anosognosia, a condition in which someone is unaware of or unable to recognize changes caused by an illness. Anosognosia can occur with Alzheimer’s disease and other forms of dementia. It is not denial or a choice. Repeatedly trying to convince someone that they are confused or incapable may not change their understanding and can instead lead to frustration or distress.

Consider what might be behind the “no.” Are they afraid of leaving home? Does accepting help feel like losing control? Are they uncomfortable with someone new entering their space?

Recognizing what is behind the concern can change how you approach the conversation.

READ: Tips for Communicating With an Individual With Alzheimer’s

Signs That More Help May Be Needed

Not every refusal means someone needs to move to Memory Support.

A person in the earlier stages of dementia may still be able to live safely at home, particularly when family, friends or professional caregivers can provide appropriate assistance.

What matters most is how the person is managing from day to day. Changes that may signal a need for additional help include:

  • Getting lost in familiar places or wandering
  • Falls or increasing difficulty with mobility
  • Missing medications or taking them incorrectly
  • Leaving appliances on or other household safety concerns
  • Difficulty preparing food or eating regularly
  • Increasing confusion that interferes with familiar routines or everyday decisions
  • Difficulty bathing, dressing or maintaining personal hygiene without assistance
  • Difficulty managing bills or financial decisions that create a risk of missed payments, scams or financial loss
  • A family caregiver who is no longer able to safely manage their loved one’s increasing care needs

Needing more help does not automatically mean someone can no longer make decisions for themselves. Those are separate questions, and decision-making ability can vary.

Before speaking with a health care professional, write down specific changes you’ve noticed, when they began and how often they occur. Examples can help the care team better understand the concerns and discuss what additional support may be appropriate.

If you are unsure whether recent changes indicate a need for additional care, a  physician or dementia care team can help to provide a clearer picture of what has changed and what options are available.

READ: Normal Aging vs. Dementia: How to Tell the Difference

Start With Conversation, Not Correction

When a person with dementia refuses care, begin by listening to their concerns rather than trying to convince them that they need help. Understanding the emotions behind the refusal can make the conversation more productive while helping preserve their sense of independence and control.  Facts and logic may not resolve the disagreement when dementia affects how the person understands the situation.

A more compassionate approach begins by listening.

Try to hear what the person is communicating rather than immediately correcting the details of what they are saying. “I don’t need anyone here” may really mean “I don’t want a stranger in my home.” “I’m not moving” may mean “I’m afraid of losing everything familiar to me.”

A few approaches can make these conversations more productive:

  • Acknowledge the emotion. You do not have to agree with every statement to recognize fear, frustration or uncertainty.
  • Keep explanations simple. Too much information at once can become overwhelming.
  • Offer manageable choices. Two clear options can preserve a sense of control without creating more confusion.
  • Avoid arguing. If the conversation becomes upsetting, give it time and return to the subject later.
  • Choose a calm moment. Conversations may be easier when the person is rested and comfortable.
  • Pay attention to nonverbal cues. Tone, facial expressions and body language may tell you as much as words.

EverTrue’s StillYou® philosophy reflects a similar idea: dementia does not erase the individual. Knowing someone’s history, preferences, relationships, interests and strengths can help families and caregivers respond to the person rather than only to the diagnosis.

There May Be Options Before a Move

When an older adult or parent is refusing help, a permanent move may not be the best or only option.

If the person can remain at home safely, introducing assistance gradually may give them time to become more comfortable receiving it. Options might include in-home care, meal or transportation services, adult day programs, care management or respite care.

EverTrue Anywhere Care offers services for older adults who want to receive additional assistance wherever they call home. These services are available in the Greater St. Louis area and portions of Illinois.

For people living with dementia and their caregivers, EverTrue GUIDE is another valuable resource. Available in the Greater St. Louis area and Springfield, Illinois, the program is part of the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services Guiding an Improved Dementia Experience Model. Eligible participants can access dementia care navigation, individualized care planning, caregiver education, 24/7 access to a care team member and other resources.

EXPLORE: EverTrue GUIDE

For some families, in-home assistance and dementia care navigation provide a middle ground between managing care independently and considering a move to Memory Support.

Can You Force Someone With Dementia Into Care?

This is one of the hardest questions families may face, and there is no universal answer.

A person living with dementia who has the legal capacity to make a particular care decision generally retains the right to make that decision.

Having power of attorney does not necessarily mean a family member can immediately override those choices, either. The authority granted depends on the legal documents, the person’s decision-making capacity and applicable state law.

If a person can no longer make certain decisions, an appointed health care agent or another legally authorized representative may be able to act on their behalf. If appropriate documents are not already in place, families may need to explore guardianship or other legal options through the courts.

Because these rules vary by state and situation, consult the primary care physician and an elder law attorney if questions about capacity or legal authority arise.

These conversations are better to have before circumstances become urgent. Advance directives, powers of attorney and discussions about future care give someone with dementia more opportunity to express their preferences while they are able to participate in those decisions.

Easing the Transition Into Memory Support

When a move to Memory Support becomes necessary, familiar routines, meaningful belongings and information about the person’s life can help make the transition less overwhelming. A setting designed for people living with dementia can provide greater structure, specialized care and opportunities for meaningful engagement, but adjusting to new surroundings can still take time.

At EverTrue, the StillYou® philosophy recognizes the person beyond the diagnosis, including their abilities, interests, individuality and life story. Sharing those details can help the care team get to know your loved one as an individual.

READ: What Is Memory Care Assisted Living and When Is It Needed?

Think about the details that help someone truly know your loved one. What music do they enjoy? What did they do for work? Which routines are important? What makes them laugh? What tends to make them anxious? Sharing those details can give the care team a fuller picture of the person beyond their medical history.

EverTrue’s resource on moving a parent with dementia also recommends helping the person become familiar with the community before moving when appropriate and bringing meaningful items such as photographs, favorite foods and memorabilia. Maintaining family relationships and familiar traditions after the move can provide continuity as well.

READ: How to Move a Parent With Dementia to Assisted Living

A thoughtful transition carries familiar parts of the person’s life into their new surroundings, including the relationships, routines and belongings that help them feel more at home.

Remember the Caregiver, Too

Family caregivers need support, too. Dementia care navigation, respite services, education and help from family or friends can make care-giving responsibilities more manageable. Caring for someone living with dementia can involve constant decisions, coordination and worry. Family caregivers may spend so much time thinking about their loved one that their own well-being becomes an afterthought.

Overwhelmed caregivers are always encouraged to ask for assistance. Dementia care navigation, respite services, caregiver education and support groups can all provide useful resources. Family and friends may be able to help with specific needs, too, from transportation and errands to spending an afternoon with your loved one.

older adult mother with dementia interacting with daughter

Frequently Asked Questions About Refusing Dementia Care

Why does a person with dementia refuse help?

There can be many reasons. Someone may fear losing independence, feel uncomfortable with unfamiliar caregivers or not recognize that their abilities have changed. Anosognosia can also make a person genuinely unaware of changes caused by dementia.

What should I do when a person with dementia refuses care?

Begin by trying to identify the concern behind the refusal. Avoid arguing, introduce assistance gradually when appropriate and involve the person’s health care team if health or safety concerns are increasing.

Can someone with dementia decide where they live?

A dementia diagnosis does not automatically remove a person’s decision-making rights. Capacity can vary depending on the individual and the specific decision. If there are concerns about whether someone understands the consequences of a decision, seek an appropriate professional assessment.

When might Memory Support be appropriate?

Memory Support may be worth considering when dementia is creating safety concerns, a person needs more supervision or structure, or providing care at home has become difficult for family caregivers to manage. A health care professional can assess the situation and discuss available options.

Finding a Way Forward

When a person living with dementia refuses care, there may not be one conversation or one decision that resolves everything.

Start by listening to what the person is expressing. Preserve their voice wherever you can, pay attention to meaningful changes and bring in health care professionals when you need guidance. Exploring resources before circumstances become urgent can also give your family more time to consider the options.

Moving forward may take patience, flexibility and more than one conversation. Through it all, the person’s dignity, voice and well-being should remain at the center of each decision.

Explore Memory Support at EverTrue.